At first glance, a $199 door may seem like a bargain. After all, it looks nice enough, gets the job done, and saves money compared to solid wood options. But when it comes to doors, the cheapest option often ends up being the most expensive. From durability issues to hidden replacement costs, low-quality doors can chip away at your investment over time.

At Nick’s Building Supply, we’ve seen how the difference between a budget door and a quality solid wood door impacts homeowners for years after installation. Here’s why that “deal” may not be such a deal after all.

Shorter Lifespan, More Replacements

Budget doors are often made from hollow core or low-density fiberboard (MDF). While lightweight and inexpensive, these materials simply don’t stand up to daily wear and tear. They’re prone to dents, scratches, and warping from humidity.

A $199 door may need replacing within a few years, while a solid wood door can last decades—making the investment far more cost-effective in the long run.

Limited Insulation and Energy Efficiency

Cheaper doors don’t just compromise on strength—they often lack proper insulation. That means drafts in the winter, heat loss in the summer, and higher utility bills year-round. Solid wood doors, on the other hand, naturally insulate better, helping to improve energy efficiency and comfort inside your home.

Aesthetics That Don’t Last

Many low-cost doors come with thin veneers or artificial finishes that can peel, chip, or discolor over time. What looked “good enough” on day one often shows wear quickly. By contrast, maple, oak, and other solid wood doors from Nick’s Building Supply maintain their beauty, can be refinished if needed, and add timeless value to your home.

Hidden Costs of “Cheap” Doors

That $199 price tag doesn’t account for:

• Frequent replacements when the door wears out
  
• Maintenance costs from repairs or repainting
  
• Lower home value compared to quality wood doors
  

When you add it all up, the “cheap” door can end up costing more than investing in a durable, high-quality option upfront.

Invest Smart with Nick’s Building Supply

At Nick’s Building Supply, we believe your doors should be an investment in your home’s value, comfort, and style—not a recurring expense. Our solid wood doors are built to last, combining craftsmanship, beauty, and durability at a price that delivers real long-term value. Don’t settle for a door that looks good today but fails tomorrow. Choose quality now—and enjoy the benefits for years to come. For questions about our products, call our team at (219) 663-2279—we’re here to help.